An icy chill of fearfulness and justified paranoia radiates from this starkly austere and gripping movie from Sergei Loznitsa, acceptable successful Stalin’s Russia of the precocious 30s and based connected a communicative by the dissident writer and idiosyncratic Georgy Demidov, who was held successful the gulag for 14 years during the 2nd satellite warfare and harassed by the authorities until his decease successful the precocious 1980s.
The resulting movie, with its slow, extended scenes from azygous camera positions, mimics the zombie beingness of the Soviet authorities and allows a unspeakable anxiousness to accumulate: it is astir a malign bureaucracy which protects and replicates itself by infecting those who situation it with a bacillus of guilt. There is thing of Dostoevsky’s The House of the Dead and besides – with the quality of 2 strangely grinning, singing men successful a railway carriage – Kafka’s The Castle.
Loznitsa moreover allows america besides to registry that the wretched governmental captive of his communicative is simply a seasoned of Stalin’s brutal conflict to suppress the Ukrainian nationalist Symon Petliura. And fixed the nightmarish claustrophobia and disorientation successful the scenes successful cells, authoritative corridors, staircases and authorities antechambers, determination is possibly a filmic footnote successful the information that Demidov worked for the idiosyncratic Lev Landau, the taxable of Ilya Khrzhanovsky’s immense and profoundly pessimistic multi-movie installation task Dau successful 2020.
The archetypal authoritative of the rubric is Kornyev, played by Aleksandr Kuznetsov, an idealistic young lawyer, fixed a startlingly aboriginal promotion to a authorities authoritative relation – his beardless younker fascinates and irritates the grizzled aged time-servers with whom helium comes into contact.
He has received a bizarre “letter” from Stepniak (Aleksandr Fillipenko) an ageing and desperately sick precocious information captive successful Bryansk – written successful humor connected a portion of torn cardboard (which has escaped the bonfire that situation authorities marque of protestation letters similar these). The missive alleges that the information services, the NKVD, are without notation to the regularisation of law, utilizing the prisons and judicial strategy to torture and execution an full older procreation of enactment veterans similar him, to bring successful a fanatically loyal but callow and incompetent cohort of Stalin loyalists.
The situation authorities marque the politely persistent Kornyev hold hours earlier being allowed to sojourn Stepniak successful his cell, transparently hoping helium volition conscionable springiness up and spell distant – Loznitsa shows this weaponised inertia is the accepted authoritative attack to petitioners everyplace successful the Soviet Union.

They besides assertion that the prisoner’s sick wellness and imaginable corruption mean Kornyev truly should “postpone” his visit. It is an evident obfuscation and yet the thought of getting infected by Stepniak has a weird and queasy relevance.
Horrified by Stepniak’s appalling information and the grounds of torture, and alert of Stepniak’s ain respected ineligible assistance and expertise (he is possibly the 2nd authoritative of the title), Kornyev gets connected a bid to Moscow to rise his concerns with the highest imaginable authorization – convinced that the locals volition bash thing – and this is the deadpan main authoritative Vyshinsky (Anatoliy Beliy) who makes Kornyev hold hours conscionable similar the situation politician and listens to his explosive allegations with unsettlingly attentive calm.
From here, determination are much bizarre hints of an occult conspiracy to frighten and deter and incorporate Kornyev – meetings with radical who look to person thing to bash with each different but who, similar the assorted neighbours successful Rosemary’s Baby, are successful information connected. On the bid to Moscow, Kornyev encounters a garrulous aged worker with a woody limb who is an eerie doppelganger of the captive Stepniak (and played by the aforesaid actor) and who makes wisecracks astir young Kornyev being a virgin which are to beryllium uncannily echoed later.
In the authorities building, Kornyev meets a young antheral who claims to beryllium his law-school contemporary, pointedly asking astir this lawsuit helium is pursuing – but Kornyev can’t retrieve ever having met him before. And astir disturbingly of all, Kornyev runs into a unusual man, possibly a petitioner, who stands up against the partition motionless, evidently paralysed with fear, hoping that nary authoritative idiosyncratic volition speech to him and who asks Kornyev successful a debased susurration which is the mode retired of there. Perhaps Kornyev himself should himself go precise inconspicuous and motionless earlier making his ain exit.
It is simply a precise disturbing parable of the insidious micro-processes of tyranny.
-
Two Prosecutors screened astatine the Cannes movie festival