Depoliticising Eurovision 'impossible', experts say

The Eurovision Song Contest is meant to beryllium astir celebrating euphony and taste diversity, but authorities inevitably seeps in, challenging the competition's long-standing assertion to neutrality.

Hopeful artists drawn from 37 countries volition vie successful this year's contention successful the Swiss metropolis of Basel starting adjacent week, with the large finale connected May 17.

Politics is officially barred from the event, but arsenic with astir years, organisers volition person their hands afloat striving to support tensions implicit civilization wars and conflicts similar Israel's warfare successful Gaza from spilling into the glitzy festivities.

Experts hold that is simply a gangly order.

"It's intolerable to depoliticise the event," Dean Vuletic, a historiographer and the writer of the publication "Postwar Europe and the Eurovision Song Contest", told AFP.

"It is wholly impossible," agreed Jess Carniel, an subordinate prof astatine the University of Southern Queensland successful Australia.

"With everyone competing nether their nationalist flag... determination is ever an undercurrent of politics."

From the inception of the contention astir 70 years ago, the European Broadcasting Union (EBU), which organises Eurovision, has insisted connected its non-political nature.

But authorities person been omnipresent, from an Austrian protestation implicit Spain's Franco dictatorship successful 1969 to calls for European unity arsenic the Soviet Union broke isolated and Eastern European countries joined the contention successful the aboriginal 1990s.

- Mass protests -

Before 1998 erstwhile Eurovision stopped requiring countries to execute successful their nationalist language, immoderate beardown governmental sentiments expressed successful songs garnered small attention.

Greece submitted a opus successful 1976 slamming Turkey implicit its penetration of Cyprus, "but it was successful Greek and determination was not overmuch attention", Lisanne Wilken, an subordinate prof successful European studies astatine Denmark's Aarhus University, told AFP.

Since then, accrued media attraction and the anticipation to enactment distant messages successful English has meant that for "anyone who wants attraction for a cause, Eurovision is simply a truly bully spot to go", she said.

More caller expressions of governmental condemnation person surely not gone unnoticed.

Russia's warfare successful Ukraine dominated the sermon astir the events successful 2022, erstwhile Ukraine won the contention and Russia was barred, and again successful 2023.

And past year, Israel's warfare successful Gaza formed a agelong shadiness implicit the event, erstwhile thousands of demonstrators protested successful the Swedish metropolis of Malmo against Israeli entrant Eden Golan taking part.

Demonstrations are already planned against Israel's information this year, with Yuval Raphael -- who survived Hamas's deadly onslaught wrong Israel connected October 7, 2023 that sparked the warfare successful Gaza -- owed to execute her opus "New Day Will Rise".

- New emblem rules -

Experts accidental they bash not expect protests connected the aforesaid level arsenic past year.

One reason, Vuletic suggested, was that "the run against Israel past twelvemonth was not successful".

"No state boycotted Eurovision due to the fact that of Israel" and the state garnered a precocious score, helium pointed out.

Experts besides said the EBU's instauration of caller rules whitethorn person an impact.

The organisers person adopted a caller emblem policy, barring contestants from displaying flags different than that of the federation they represent, but loosening restrictions connected the flags assemblage members tin display.

Eurovision explained that it aimed to "strike a equilibrium to guarantee that our audiences and artists tin explicit their enthusiasm and identities, (while providing) much clarity for the delegations erstwhile it comes to authoritative spaces".

"I deliberation the determination was mostly inspired by the references to Palestine past year," Vuletic said.

- Trump effect? -

Wilken meantime warned that the caller argumentation could "backfire a small bit", with the prohibition connected contestants waving Pride flags, for instance, perchance work arsenic portion of "the warfare connected woke".

Carniel agreed, pointing retired that determination had been "a spot of a backlash against alleged individuality authorities astatine the opus contest, and disapproval of the grade to which Eurovision has truly leaned into queer fandom".

By barring contestants from waving Pride flags oregon different symbols supporting LGBTQ rights, the organisers mightiness "oddly beryllium trying to bring much radical in" by emphasising that the contention "is not an exclusively queer event".

The United States whitethorn not beryllium portion of the contest, but experts said President Donald Trump's anti-diversity messaging could energise efforts by blimpish forces successful Europe anxious to escaped Eurovision of its LGBTQ-friendly identity.

At the aforesaid time, the Trump administration's attacks connected European countries could fortify the contest's absorption connected forging a communal European identity, Carniel suggested.

"Given the existent governmental climate," she said, "that thought of European unity against the extracurricular is simply a beardown thing."

nl/rjm/giv/sco